We’re moving our forums to a new platform.

You can still browse and search existing topics, but you can no longer create new topics or post replies.

For questions, technical issues, or feature requests, please don’t hesitate to contact our support team at support@advancedinstaller.com.

Thank you for your understanding!

cmconti
Posts: 9
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2024 5:00 pm

Problem in 23.9 with silent install of pre-req and post-mainfeature subinstalls

Full details of this including logs and the .aip files were emailed a few days ago.

* After upgrading from 21.9 to 23.9 we have run into a problem with silent install behavior.
* Our main installer has some pre- and post- installs
* The desired behavior (which worked in 21.9) was when the main installer is run with '/qn' or '/qn+':
** the main install is silent (except for the optional final confirmation dialog when using '/qn+)
** the pre- installs are silent
** the post- installs show full UI
* After fixes, the observed behavior with the upgraded aip when run with /qn+:
** The pre installs are no longer silent, showing full UI
** The post install does not run at all
* The tested command lines were:
** /qn INST_POST=true
** /qn+ INST_POST=true

From the original 21.9 .aip file: (I've edited the names for posting)

Code: Select all

    <ROW PrereqKey="PREREQINSTALLEREXE" DisplayName="Pre Req Installer" VersionMin="10.1.1.0" SetupFileUrl="Prerequisites\PreReqInstaller.exe" Location="0" ExactSize="0" WinNTVersions="Windows 7 RTM x86" WinNT64Versions="Windows 7 RTM x64, Windows Server 2008 R2 RTM x64" Operator="1" ComLine="[AI_PREREQ_UILEVEL_SWITCH]" NoUiComLine="/qn" Options="myn" TargetName="PreReqInstaller.exe"/>
    <ROW PrereqKey="POSTFEATUREINSTALL" DisplayName="Post Feature Installer" VersionMin="1.0.0.0" SetupFileUrl="Prerequisites\PostFeatureInstaller.exe" Location="0" ExactSize="0" Operator="1" NoUiComLine="/qn" Options="fi" TargetName="PostFeatureInstaller.exe" Feature="PostFeatureInstall" InstallCondition="INST_POST ~= &quot;true&quot;"/>
After the initial upgrade to 23.9 (loading in 23.9 and saving), these lines became:

Code: Select all

    <ROW PrereqKey="PREREQINSTALLEREXE" DisplayName="Pre Req Installer" VersionMin="10.1.1.0" SetupFileUrl="Prerequisites\PreReqInstaller.exe" Location="0" ExactSize="0" WinNTVersions="Windows 7 RTM x86" WinNT64Versions="Windows 7 RTM x64, Windows Server 2008 R2 RTM x64" Operator="1" NoUiComLine=" /qn" Options="myn" TargetName="PreReqInstaller.exe"/>
    <ROW PrereqKey="POSTFEATUREINSTALL" DisplayName="Post Feature Installer" VersionMin="1.0.0.0" SetupFileUrl="Prerequisites\PostFeatureInstaller.exe" Location="0" ExactSize="0" Operator="1" NoUiComLine=" /qn" Options="fi" TargetName="PreReqInstaller.exe" Feature="PostFeatureInstall" InstallCondition="INST_POST ~= &quot;true&quot;"/>
With this version, running with /qn INST_POST=true caused the post install to also be silent
* TBH this feels like the result of a bug fix, since the post install line has a NoUiComLine.
* We fixed this issue by removing NoUiComLine from the post install line, which left us with these:

Code: Select all

    <ROW PrereqKey="PREREQINSTALLEREXE" DisplayName="Pre Req Installer" VersionMin="10.1.1.0" SetupFileUrl="Prerequisites\PreReqInstaller.exe" Location="0" ExactSize="0" WinNTVersions="Windows 7 RTM x86" WinNT64Versions="Windows 7 RTM x64, Windows Server 2008 R2 RTM x64" Operator="1" NoUiComLine=" /qn" Options="myn" TargetName="PreReqInstaller.exe"/>
    <ROW PrereqKey="POSTFEATUREINSTALL" DisplayName="Post Feature Installer" VersionMin="1.0.0.0" SetupFileUrl="Prerequisites\PostFeatureInstaller.exe" Location="0" ExactSize="0" Operator="1" Options="fi" TargetName="PreReqInstaller.exe" Feature="PostFeatureInstall" InstallCondition="INST_POST ~= &quot;true&quot;"/>
With this version, running the main installer with /qn+ INST_POST=true:
* The pre installs are no longer silent, showing full UI
* The post install does not run at all

I did try adding ComLine="[AI_PREREQ_UILEVEL_SWITCH]" BasicUiComLine="[AI_PREREQ_UILEVEL_SWITCH]" to the pre install, but there was no change in behavior
Liviu
Posts: 1420
Joined: Tue Jul 13, 2021 11:29 am
Contact: Website

Re: Problem in 23.9 with silent install of pre-req and post-mainfeature subinstalls

Hello,

Please note that I've replied to your e-mail.

Best regards,
Liviu
________________________________________
Liviu Sandu - Advanced Installer Team
Follow us: Twitter - Facebook - YouTube
cmconti
Posts: 9
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2024 5:00 pm

Re: Problem in 23.9 with silent install of pre-req and post-mainfeature subinstalls

Attaching qn+ issue reproduction files
AdvInstTest.7z
logs, aips, and source files with .exe renamed
(158.5 KiB) Downloaded 164 times
Liviu
Posts: 1420
Joined: Tue Jul 13, 2021 11:29 am
Contact: Website

Re: Problem in 23.9 with silent install of pre-req and post-mainfeature subinstalls

Hello,

Thank you for sending the reproduction files.

I have received the archive and I am currently investigating the /qn+ behavior.

I will get back to you as soon as I have more information.

Best regards,
Liviu
________________________________________
Liviu Sandu - Advanced Installer Team
Follow us: Twitter - Facebook - YouTube

Return to “Common Problems”