daniking
Posts: 5
Joined: Wed Sep 28, 2005 10:13 pm

Organization of Features and Components

Unless I have overlooked a feature, I have found that it is very tedious to organize files.

I have multiple video files that I want to be organized into a "Audio & Video" Feature. the problem/annoyance that I am running into is that AI automatically collects like files into a single component. Ex:


Audio & Video <--Desired Feature
  • 1.saf <-- Component
    • 2.asf <-- Resources
      3.asf
In order to seperate 3.asf I have to right-click and select "Move to new component". Then I have to move each component one-by-one up into my desired feature, which takes a LONG time. Especially if I am changing my files regularly.

It would be nice to be able to move a selected group of components simultaneously into a desired feature.[/list]
ciprian
Posts: 259
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2005 12:56 pm
Location: Craiova, Romania
Contact: Website

Hi,

Thank you very much for your suggestion.

We will consider adding this feature on our to do list.

Also, could you please tell me why do you want to place each file in a separate component if you are going to move all the components into one feature? Why not leave them in the same component and place that component in the desired feature?

All the best,
Ciprian
Ciprian Burca
Advanced Installer Team
http://www.advancedinstaller.com
daniking
Posts: 5
Joined: Wed Sep 28, 2005 10:13 pm

Also, could you please tell me why do you want to place each file in a separate component if you are going to move all the components into one feature? Why not leave them in the same component and place that component in the desired feature?
For one, I am not entirely sure how AI is deciding to group each compnent. For example, AI is forcing the following hierarchy:
  • autorun.bat
    • index.html
where "autorun.bat" does not exist anymore.

I see your point as to dragging the whole component into a feature and leaving it bundled. The dissadvantage to this method is that you have to expand each component in order to 'discover' all the resources grouped under that one component. For checking that the installer package is ready for release it is easier to verify that all the appropriate resources are present if they are listed individually.

Am I correct in saying that AI will automatically make a resource its own component if it has an individual shortcut linking to it? Thus, listing the shortcut as a resource for this component?
ciprian
Posts: 259
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2005 12:56 pm
Location: Craiova, Romania
Contact: Website

Hi,

1. When organizing the resources into components, Advanced Installer follows these guide lines set by Microsoft:

0. different folders means different components
1. EXE, OCX, DLL, etc. have each their own component
2. Shortcut targets get their own components with them being the key
3. Help files have their own components
4. All remaining files get grouped into one "generic" component per folder

Microsoft also recommends:

" Try to keep the total number of components low to improve performance."

2. When a file is the target for a shortcut it is automatically placed in a separate component.

Best regards,
Ciprian
Ciprian Burca
Advanced Installer Team
http://www.advancedinstaller.com

Return to “Feature Requests”